How to Choose the Right ERP System

10 Expert Tips Every Indian Business Owner Must Know in 2025

Table of Contents

1.  Introduction: The Decision That Shapes Your Next Five Years. 
2. Tip 1- Solve real problems first, then think about features.
3. Tip 2- Be clear about what to change and what not to change.
4. Tip 3- Choose an ERP that fits your business size, not the vendor’s big promises.
5. Tip 4- Make compliance your base, not just another feature.
6. Tip 5- Consider the total cost of ownership, not just the upfront price.
7. Tip 6- Choose a system that connects well with your other tools.
8. Tip 7- Look for real scalability, not promises on paper.
9. Tip 8- Test it properly using your real business data.
10. Tip 9- If your team can’t use it easily, it won’t work.
11. Tip 10- Evaluate the vendor as carefully as the software.
12. Quick Comparison: Cloud vs On-Premise ERP
13. ERP Selection Checklist: What to Review Before You Sign
14. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
15. Conclusion: The Right ERP is a Foundation, Not Just a Tool

Introduction: The Decision That Shapes Your Next Five Years.

Picture this: you run a textile trading business out of Surat with four warehouses and a growing team of 60 people. Spreadsheets have kept things moving until now, but last quarter two shipments went out without proper invoicing, your accountant spent eleven days reconciling GST returns, and you still cannot answer a basic question, which product is actually profitable after logistics costs?

You know you need an ERP. You open your browser, search, and are immediately buried under product pages, pricing tiers, demo requests, and acronyms. Every vendor claims to be the “best fit” for businesses exactly like yours.

The hard truth is this: an ERP implemented well becomes the operating system of your business, the thing that holds every department together and gives you the information to make faster, smarter decisions. An ERP implemented poorly, or chosen without rigour, can cost you months of productivity, crores in hidden expenses, and the goodwill of the people who have to use it every day.

This guide is not a vendor comparison. It is a decision-making framework built specifically for Indian business owners who want to approach ERP selection with clarity, confidence, and zero regret. Work through these ten tips before you sign anything, and you will be in a fundamentally stronger position than the majority of companies that rush the process.

Tip 1- Solve real problems first, then think about features.

Most ERP searches begin in the wrong place. A business owner sits through three demos, gets excited about a live analytics dashboard, and starts imagining what their operations could look like. The problem is that none of those demos showed you how the system handles your specific inventory mismatch between your warehouse in Bengaluru and your distribution hub in Chennai. They showed you what the vendor wants to show you.

The only reliable starting point is your actual pain. Before you open a single product brochure, spend two or three hours documenting where your business genuinely hurts. Walk through a typical Monday morning with each department head. Ask your finance team how long month-end close takes and where it breaks down. Ask your warehouse supervisor how long it takes to locate a specific SKU. Ask your sales team how often they have to call someone to check stock before quoting a customer.

Write those moments down, not as abstract requirements, but as concrete scenarios. “Every Friday we spend three hours manually reconciling purchase orders against supplier invoices because the data lives in two different places.” That is an ERP problem with a measurable cost. Features without a problem they solve are just noise.

💡 Real-World Example:

A multi-outlet pharmacy chain in Hyderabad came to their ERP selection knowing they needed “better inventory management.” After a structured internal audit, they discovered the real issue: batch and expiry tracking was done manually, and near-expiry stock was routinely missed. This single finding changed their entire ERP shortlist, they focused only on systems with automated batch tracking and expiry alerts, and ignored everything else.

Tip 2- Be clear about what to change and what not to change.

Every ERP comes with embedded assumptions about how business processes should work. Some of those assumptions will match your operations. Many will not. Before you begin evaluation, you need an honest internal conversation about which differences are acceptable and which are not.

Go through your five most important business processes. For each one, ask: is this a core competitive strength, or is it simply how we have always done it? Your custom credit-approval workflow for large B2B buyers might be a genuine differentiator that keeps clients loyal, that is a non-negotiable, and the ERP must accommodate it. But the way you manually allocate freight costs across product lines might simply be a workaround for not having the right tools, that is negotiable, and a good ERP should replace it with something better.

The businesses that struggle most with ERP are those that insist on replicating every existing process inside the new system. ERP implementation is also a process improvement opportunity. The discipline is knowing which improvements to welcome and which compromises to refuse.

⚠️ Common Mistake to Avoid:

Avoid building an ERP brief by simply listing everything you do today. A brief that says “we want everything to work exactly as it does now” typically leads to expensive over-customization, delays, and a system that is inflexible the moment your business evolves.

Tip 3- Choose an ERP that fits your business size, not the vendor’s big promises.

ERP vendors, especially the larger ones, are expert at making you feel like you need more than you do. In demos they will show you AI-powered demand forecasting, blockchain-based supply chain traceability, and predictive analytics dashboards, all of which are genuinely impressive, and almost none of which your business needs right now.

Buying an enterprise-grade ERP when you are a 40-crore turnover company with eight locations is one of the most reliable ways to create an implementation nightmare. You will pay for modules nobody uses, your team will struggle with complexity designed for organizations ten times your size, and the implementation timeline will stretch because there is simply too much to configure for your actual requirements.

The smarter approach is to identify your honest tier. For most Indian businesses between ₹2 crore and ₹75 crore in annual turnover, a well-chosen mid-market ERP with modular architecture, meaning you can activate additional capabilities as you grow, will outperform a bloated enterprise system every single time. Start with the modules you will actively use on day one. Build from there.

💡 Peddle Plus One ERP Perspective:

At Peddle Plus One ERP, we consistently see that growing Indian businesses need four things done brilliantly before anything else: multi-location inventory visibility, integrated GST-compliant accounting, a clean purchase order workflow, and reliable sales reporting. Get those four right, and the foundation is solid for everything that follows.

Tip 4- Make compliance your base, not just another feature.

For any business operating in India, GST compliance is not optional and it is not a checkbox. Yet a surprising number of ERP vendors , particularly those with products originally built for international markets they treat Indian taxation as a customization layer bolted onto a global platform. That approach creates friction that compounds over time.

Your ERP must handle the full Indian compliance stack natively, not through third-party workarounds or manual workarounds. This means automated GST calculation across all invoice types, e-invoicing generation that meets IRN standards, e-Way Bill creation directly from the system, GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B preparation with reconciliation, TDS and TCS deduction and reporting. As regulations continue to evolve, the GST Council has made over 900 amendments since the tax was introduced , you also need to know how the vendor handles compliance updates. Are they included in your subscription, or are they billed as separate customizations?

The right question to ask every vendor before anything else: “Show me a live GST reconciliation report. Show me how the system generates an e-invoice and what happens if there is a mismatch with the GSTN portal.” If they hesitate, or route you to a third-party add-on, reconsider.

Compliance Checklist: What Your ERP Must Handle

✔ Automated GST calculation for all supply types (B2B, B2C, exports, RCM)

✔ e-Invoicing with IRN generation and QR code embedding

✔ e-Way Bill generation integrated with logistics workflows

✔ GSTR-1, GSTR-2, and GSTR-3B preparation with reconciliation reports

✔ TDS deduction, TCS collection, and 26AS reconciliation

✔ Audit-ready financial reports with full transaction traceability

Tip 5- Consider the total cost of ownership, not just the upfront price.

The monthly subscription fee or the one-time license cost is the smallest number in your ERP budget. It is also the number that gets the most attention during vendor comparisons, which is why so many businesses are blindsided by what comes after they sign.

A genuine Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) analysis spreads across five years and includes every rupee the system will cost you. Implementation and configuration fees are typically 1.5 to 3 times the annual license cost for mid-market systems. Data migration - cleaning, formatting, and moving your existing records into the new system is consistently underestimated and can run into significant time and money for businesses with years of legacy data. Training costs money both directly (trainer fees, materials) and indirectly (the productivity lost while your team is learning). Customization costs grow over time as your business changes. And for cloud systems, subscription fees compound year on year.

The goal is not to find the cheapest system. It is to find the system with the strongest return on investment across its full operational lifetime. An ERP that costs more upfront but reduces your month-end close from ten days to three, eliminates your GST reconciliation errors, and gives your management team real-time visibility into profitability will pay for itself many times over. The cheap option that leaves you with three years of workarounds and hidden support costs will not.

💡 How to Compare Vendors Fairly:

Ask every vendor for a fully itemized 3-year cost projection, including implementation, training, data migration, support, and estimated customization costs. Then calculate cost per active user per month across all three years. That single number allows a genuinely apples-to-apples comparison across systems with very different pricing structures.

Tip 6- Choose a system that connects well with your other tools.

No business runs on a single platform. Your ERP will need to communicate with a range of other systems, some of which you use today and others you will adopt as you grow. How well your ERP integrates with those systems is not a technical footnote, it directly determines whether your team actually gets value from the software or spends their day bridging gaps manually.

The integration question is particularly important for Indian businesses, where the technology ecosystem is rich and varied. Your ERP may need to connect with Tally for legacy accounting data, WhatsApp Business API for customer communication and invoice delivery, UPI and payment gateway systems for real-time payment reconciliation, e-commerce platforms like Flipkart or your own Shopify store, third-party logistics providers for shipment tracking, and HRMS or payroll tools. Each of these integrations that requires manual intervention rather than automated data flow is a daily tax on your team’s time and a source of data inconsistency.

Before evaluating integration capabilities, list every tool your business currently uses and mark each one as critical, important, or nice-to-have. For critical integrations, demand a live demonstration, not a promise. Ask specifically about data synchronization frequency, is it real-time, or does it batch-update overnight? Ask who is responsible for maintaining integrations when the connected system updates its API.

⚠️ A Cautionary Example:

A Chennai-based FMCG distributor selected an ERP with an impressive feature set, only to discover after go-live that their e-commerce integration required a manual CSV export every morning. Their team spent 90 minutes daily entering online orders into the system, exactly the kind of manual work they had bought an ERP to eliminate. Integration gaps discovered after signing are expensive to fix.

Tip 7- Look for real scalability, not promises on paper.

Every ERP vendor will tell you their system scales. This claim is almost universal in vendor marketing, which makes it almost meaningless without evidence. What you need is not a promise - it is a demonstration of how the system has actually performed as similar businesses have grown.

Scalability has several distinct dimensions that each deserves specific investigation. Transaction volume scalability means the system can handle five or ten times your current daily orders, invoices, and inventory movements without performance degradation. User scalability means adding new staff across new departments or locations does not trigger expensive re-licensing or architectural changes. Module scalability means you can activate capabilities like manufacturing, project management, or a customer portal without replacing the underlying platform. Geographic scalability means the system can support multi-state operations with different GST registrations, multi-currency transactions if you have export operations, and potentially multiple languages for a diverse workforce.

The most reliable way to test scalability claims is to ask the vendor for three reference customers who have doubled or tripled in size while on the platform. Ask those customers directly: what changed in the system as they grew? What did it cost? Were there any performance issues during high-volume periods like Diwali or financial year-end?

💡 Peddle Plus One ERP Perspective:

Modular ERP architecture is the key marker of genuine scalability. A system where you can add a manufacturing module, a project management module, or a CRM module without replacing the core platform gives you real flexibility. Systems that require a full migration when you add capabilities are not scalable, they are a series of discrete products dressed up as a single platform.

Tip 8- Test it properly using your real business data.

A vendor demonstration is a controlled performance. The data is clean, the workflows are rehearsed, and the presenter knows exactly where to click to avoid the rough edges. What you need before committing is the opposite of that: an uncontrolled, messy, real-world test of whether the system can handle your actual operations.

A meaningful pilot has specific characteristics. It uses a representative sample of your real business data, real SKUs, real customers, and real historical transactions, rather than sanitized demo data. It tests the specific workflows that your team will use every day, not just the headline capabilities the vendor is proud of. It involves people from multiple departments: the warehouse supervisor handling a stock transfer, the accountant reconciling a purchase order, and the sales executive generating a customer-specific price quote. And it runs long enough that initial unfamiliarity wears off, and genuine usability issues typically surface within at least two weeks.

During the pilot, create a simple, structured feedback form for every participant. Ask three questions for every task they test: Was it intuitive? How many steps did it take compared to how you do it today? Would you be confident doing this without training six months from now? The answers will tell you far more than any feature comparison matrix.

💡 Peddle Plus One ERP Pro Tip:

Pay special attention to how the system behaves for your least tech-savvy users during the pilot. If your senior warehouse staff member, who has never used a computer beyond WhatsApp, can learn to complete a stock transfer without help within two days, your adoption challenge is manageable. If they cannot, you will be fighting user resistance for years.

Tip 9- If your team can’t use it easily, it won’t work.

This is the tip that separates businesses that get a return from their ERP investment from those who do not. The most technically capable ERP in the world delivers zero value if your team does not use it correctly, consistently, and willingly. And the number-one reason ERP implementations fail to deliver expected benefits is not technical failure; it is human resistance.

User experience during evaluation should be evaluated with the same rigour as functionality. Count the clicks required to complete common tasks. Check whether the system has a mobile application that works well on affordable Android devices, not just on the latest flagship phones, because that is what your field staff actually use. Look at the quality of the dashboards: are they genuinely informative and actionable, or are they visual decoration that does not connect to what your managers actually need to know?

But user experience is only half the picture. Change management - the deliberate work of helping people transition from how they work today to how they will work with the new system, it must begin during the selection phase, not after go-live.

Involve frontline staff in the requirements-gathering process. Let them participate in the pilot. Explain not just what is changing but why, and specifically what it means for their individual role. Identify internal champions in each department people who are enthusiastic about the change and can support their colleagues through the learning curve.

The businesses that succeed with ERP treat go-live as the beginning of a behavior change program, not as the finish line of a software project. Budget time and resources for post-go-live coaching, a helpdesk for user questions, and regular check-ins at 30, 60, and 90 days to catch resistance before it becomes entrenchment.

Tip 10- Evaluate the vendor as carefully as the software.

You are not buying a product. You are entering a relationship that will touch your core operations every working day for the next five to seven years. The vendor you choose will have access to your business data, will be responsible for keeping your compliance current, will be the organization you call when something breaks at 9 PM on the last day of the financial quarter. That relationship deserves the same due diligence as any major business partnership.

Start with financial stability. An ERP vendor that goes out of business or gets acquired mid-contract creates a potentially catastrophic situation for your operations. Ask for evidence of the company’s longevity and financial health. Investigate their product release history: are updates released on a clear schedule, and do they include genuine improvements rather than just compliance patches? Read reviews on independent platforms from businesses with profiles similar to yours.

Support quality is often the most important factor in long-term satisfaction with an ERP, and it is the factor that is hardest to assess before you sign. Ask where the support team is based, for Indian businesses, a vendor whose support team operates in Indian time zones and understands the Indian compliance calendar is vastly more valuable than a globally-distributed team. Ask about guaranteed response times and escalation procedures. And then do something most businesses neglect: call their support line before you commit. Pose as a new user with a simple question. How long does it take to reach a human? How helpful is that human? That interaction is a preview of your future.

The Question Every Vendor Should Answer:

Ask directly: “If we decide to leave your platform in three years, what does data export look like, and what does that process cost us?” A vendor who is confident in their product will answer this question calmly and completely. A vendor who deflects or makes data portability sound complicated is signaling that they plan to use lock-in rather than quality as their retention strategy.

Quick Comparison: Cloud vs On-Premise ERP

The hosting decision is one of the most consequential early choices in ERP selection. Here is a side-by-side view of the key considerations for Indian businesses.For most growing Indian businesses without dedicated IT infrastructure, cloud ERP offers the best balance of cost, flexibility, and support. The on-premise route makes sense primarily when regulatory requirements mandate local data storage or when you have an existing IT team and server environment that makes it economically sensible.

ERP Selection Checklist: What to Review Before You Sign

Before you commit to any ERP vendor, work through every item on this checklist. If any item is unanswered or unresolved, that is your signal to go back and get clarity before proceeding.

Discovery & Requirements

✔ Documented current business processes with specific pain points identified

✔ Defined measurable success criteria (e.g., reduce close time, cut reconciliation errors)

✔ Listed must-have features versus nice-to-have features, signed off by all department heads

✔ Identified non-negotiable processes that must be preserved vs. processes open to change

Compliance & Integration

✔ Verified live GST, e-invoicing, e-Way Bill, TDS/TCS handling in the demo environment

✔ Confirmed integration capability with all critical existing tools (list these explicitly)

✔ Tested data synchronization frequency and method for each key integration

✔ Confirmed compliance update policy (included in subscription vs. billed separately)

Commercial & Technical

✔ Received full 3-year TCO breakdown including implementation, training, and support

✔ Tested system performance and usability with your real data during a structured pilot

✔ Collected structured feedback from end-users across multiple departments

✔ Confirmed scalability through reference customers who have grown significantly on the platform

Vendor & Partnership

✔ Investigated vendor financial stability, product roadmap, and release history

✔ Called vendor support line and evaluated response time and quality

✔ Spoken with at least two reference customers with similar profile and size

✔ Received clear written answer on data portability, export format, and exit process

✔ Reviewed and understood contract terms around data ownership, SLAs, and price escalation

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: How long does a typical ERP implementation take for an Indian SME?

A: For a mid-market Indian business with 30 to 100 users across 2 to 5 locations, a well-run cloud ERP implementation typically takes between 8 and 20 weeks from kickoff to go-live. The range is wide because it depends heavily on the complexity of your data migration, the number of integrations required, and how clearly your requirements were defined before implementation started. Businesses that invest time in requirements documentation before engaging a vendor almost always see shorter implementation timelines.

Q: What is a realistic ERP budget for a business with ₹15–25 crore annual turnover?

A: For a business in that range, a sensible budget includes software costs (typically ₹3-7 lakh per year for a cloud subscription covering 10-20 users), implementation (often ₹5-15 lakh for a standard mid-market system), data migration (₹2-5 lakh depending on legacy data quality), and training (₹1-3 lakh). Total first-year outlay frequently falls between ₹12-25 lakh. These numbers vary significantly based on the vendor and the complexity of your requirements, which is why a detailed TCO exercise is essential before any commitment.

Q: Is a cloud ERP safe for storing sensitive financial and customer data?

A: Reputable cloud ERP vendors invest more in security infrastructure than most individual businesses could afford to maintain on-premise, including data encryption at rest and in transit, redundant backups, role-based access controls, and regular penetration testing. The key questions to ask any cloud vendor are: Where is our data physically stored (and does it comply with Indian data localization requirements)? What is your uptime SLA? How do you handle data breaches? Request evidence of security certifications (ISO 27001, SOC 2) before finalizing any cloud ERP contract.

Q: How do I know if an ERP vendor will still be in business in five years?

A: No vendor assessment can give you certainty, but several signals indicate stability: the vendor has been operating for more than seven years, has a published product roadmap that extends at least two years forward, has a meaningful and growing customer base, and can provide audited financial statements or investor backing evidence. Avoid vendors who are evasive about their business history or who cannot point to a clear future product vision. Also investigate whether your data can be exported in standard formats, this protects you if a vendor does shut down or change direction.

Q: What is the biggest mistake businesses make when selecting an ERP?

A: Choosing based on the demo rather than the pilot. A vendor demo is a curated performance that shows you exactly what the vendor wants you to see, with clean data and rehearsed workflows. The pilot, where your team uses the system with your real data to complete your actual tasks, is where the truth surfaces. Businesses that skip the pilot phase, or treat it as a formality rather than a serious evaluation tool, frequently discover critical usability or functionality gaps only after they have signed a multi-year contract and begun a disruptive implementation.

Q: Can a small business with fewer than 20 employees benefit from an ERP?

A: Yes, provided the ERP is appropriately sized and priced for small businesses. The benefits that matter most at this stage are typically: reliable GST-compliant invoicing, accurate inventory tracking across even one or two locations, integrated purchase and payables management, and a single source of truth for financial reporting. The mistake small businesses make is either buying an enterprise-grade system that overwhelms them with complexity, or staying with basic tools like Tally or Excel long after those tools have become limiting. A well-chosen modular ERP at the right scale is valuable from day one and grows with you.

Conclusion: The Right ERP is a Foundation, Not Just a Tool

ERP selection is not something you do quickly, and it is not something you do twice if you do it right the first time. The ten tips in this guide are not shortcuts, they are the minimum standard of diligence that an investment of this magnitude deserves. Every business that has taken the time to genuinely understand its own problems, define what success looks like, test rigorously before committing, and choose a vendor that earns trust rather than just wins a pitch has built a significantly stronger foundation for everything that follows.

The businesses that skip steps in this process are the ones that find themselves back in the market three years later, paying twice, once for the wrong system and once for the right one. The businesses that follow a disciplined approach build a digital backbone that compounds in value every year: faster decisions, cleaner compliance, more confident expansion, and a team that actually trusts its tools.

At Peddle Plus One ERP, our goal is simple: help Indian businesses make this decision once, make it well, and then build on it. We are not here to sell you software you do not need. We are here to understand your operations, ask the uncomfortable questions alongside you, and point you toward the solution that will actually serve you, that is the kind of partner you deserve in a decision this important.

Take the time this decision demands. Ask the hard questions. Demand evidence, not promises. And if you want an honest conversation about where you are in your ERP journey and what the right next step looks like for your specific business, the team at Peddle Plus One ERP is ready for that conversation.

About Peddle Plus One ERP

Peddle Plus One ERP is a digital growth platform built for Indian businesses navigating technology decisions, streamlining operations, and scaling with confidence.

What is your pain point?

Click here to get a call from Us.

peddleplus.in